Wednesday, October 03, 2012

Mayne Report: Can Mayne win a seat on the City Council?

There is speculation and wonder if Stephen Mayne can win a seat on the Council benches?  The short Answer is yes anything is possible but unlikely.

Mayne does not live in the electorate.  He lives in Templestowe and until recently he was a City of Manningham Councillor.  Mayne is an outsider and his record of local representation is not the best. There were many local residents in Templestowe who were not happy with Mayne.  774ABC Radio regually assist him in his campaigns by giving him undue air time by inviting him to speak and espouse his personal views.

Stephen Mayne can win a seat but only at the expense of the Greens second Councillor.  For Mayne to win the Greens need to fall below 15%, Jackie Watts needs to win a quota in her own right and  Mayne needs poll over 4% and collect enough preferences to stay alive in the count ahead of Rohan Lepert (Greens number two candidate).  Mayne needs to campaign against the Greens and peg back their primary vote in order to win a seat on the green leather.


Elected Candidate Group
1  LOUEY, Kevin Team Doyle
2  ONG, Ken Melbourne Living
3  OKE, Cathy The Greens
4  WOOD, Arron Team Doyle
5  PINDER-MORTIMER, Beverley Team Doyle
6  WATTS, Jackie MORGAN ELLIOTT- PROSPERITY FOR LIVEABILITY
7  CHAMBERLIN, Kevin SHANAHAN CHAMBERLIN FOR MELBOURNE
8  MAYNE, Stephen STEPHEN MAYNE
9  FOSTER, Richard OUR MELBOURNE

Analysis based on percentage of vote supplied by K*


Percentage Group Name
5.5% OUR MELBOURNE
4.0% STEPHEN MAYNE
0.3% RESIDENTS FIRST:STOP THE RATES RIP-OFF!
8.0% SHANAHAN CHAMBERLIN FOR MELBOURNE
0.1% COMMUNITY AND BUSINESS LEADERSHIP
0.1% COMMUNITY AND BUSINESS LEADERSHIP
1.2% FORWARD TOGETHER
15.0% THE GREENS
34.0% TEAM DOYLE
10.0% MORGAN ELLIOTT- PROSPERITY FOR LIVEABILITY
19.0% GARY SINGER - JOHN SO MELBOURNE LIVING
3.0% Ungrouped




Kensington Times: Reply to Residents' Association Survey

Some Kensington Issues:

We seek your views on what action do you commit yourself to campaign actively around.

What do you see as the key issue for residents in the seat of Melbourne generally and Kensington in particular. 

Specific local issues:

Reintroduction of a truck ban in Kensington Rd, Epsom Rd and Macaulay Rd.

Over the last 20 years, there have been various levels of regulation over the use of these roads by heavy vehicles.  A 24/7 ban on heavy vehicles was removed by the Kennett government.  It was replace with a limited access ban by the current government (no trucks between 7PM and 7AM).

It is not the role of Councillors to hold the answers or be responsible to every issue but to give voice and a mechanism for community issues to be properly aired and considered on their merits.  Each precinct does not exist in isolation.  It my belief that Council needs to build a proper process of expert committees that address specific issues.  These committees would have community representatives and persons who are experts in their field on them.  There should be a Transport committee that can oversee council administration and policy development on all forms of transport, Public transport, roads and bicycle network development and review State governmnet polciy as it effects the City.  

Of course issues and concerns over heavy vehicle movements need to be address to protect residential amenity.  Better access to road infrastructure, better planning and alternative need to be properly considered to meet these needs

Mandatory Height overlays

There is strong support for the concept of mandatory building height overlays (in other than declared activity zones).  The ongoing MSS process has also generated both significant interest and concern for residents

What, in your view, would constitute appropriate development in Kensington?

Again there is no one formula that can be applied to address and specific area.  Heritage and development planning controls are important to protect areas of significance.  Council's role is to oversee the process of community consultation and policy development which should be left to the professional staff and expert in their field to determine.  Residents and stakeholders should have direct input into the committee process.  Any decisions that come from the committees would be subject to final approval by the elected Council were there is no consensus or agreement.    

South Kensington Station and JJ Holland Park

The proposed Metro One link will have a portal in the proximity of JJ Holland Park (The only major open space recreational area in Kensington).  Residents are overwhelmingly opposed to any of the park being used for the portal. 

What is your view on access to or the usage of Holland Park for major infrastructure projects?

Open public space should not be seen as a Publicly Aquiered Resources Kits (PARK) for private or public development. Parks and open public space are sacrosanct and any proposal to impact on their surrounds MUST meet with community approval.

These are issues that need to discussed and resolved by an effective and functioning committee structure ensuring that stakeholders and members of the community are given a voice.  These issues do not just effect Kensington and many of the same issues are confronting all communities across Melbourne.  We have to restore community representation and participation in local democracy.  This is best achieved under the current system through the Council committee structure.  For too long Councillors have been overloaded and expected to sit on all committees and decide on every issue an d in the process they are swamped by the work load. The administration pray on this and use it to direct Council away from the issues that really matter. By divesting a degree of responsibility to the committees Councillors can hopefully focus more of their attention on oversight and further consultation ensuring that the system is functioning and the administration are held to account for their actions and policy development.  Councillors should not sit on expert committees.  They can not be judge and jury of their own proposals.

Childcare Shortage

There is an ongoing shortage of childcare in Kensington.  What would you do to facilitate additional childcare places in and around Kensington?

Again these are issues that need to be address in detail by expert committees responsible for overseeing the development of Council policy and service delivery.  The role of the committee is to facilitate community discussion and planning.  Each local precinct should be entitled to representation and a voice. Members of community organisations wishing to participate in a particular field of expertise can and should be recruited to assist in this role

Council services

What additional services do you think that council should provide to residents?

These are decisions that need to be discussed and determined in consultation with all stakeholders and community representatives. The role of the Council is to facilitate consultation and community participation to try and meet their expectations and needs. It is pointless to just be reactionary to any proposal.  Residents and Businesses need to put forward proposals and be prepared to advocate for them or against them based on its merits. As a Councillor I would not be seeking to impose my views over the process but seek to listen and support the outcomes of the stakeholder consultation assessment process.  

Taxis hits rock bottom in Melbourne Swantson Street safety trap

Taxis hit rock bottom

The menace to the bike riding public posed by Melbourne's out-of-control taxi fleet was highlighted this week when a yellow cab came to grief attempting to navigate the Swanston Street bike route.
Tens of thousands of tram passengers were delayed for hours while police, Yarra Trams officials and emergency services attempted to remove the intruder, which was blocking north-bound trams.

The cab appeared to have attempted to perform a skateboard trick along the edge bike track / tram track interface, but ended up belly down.

No vehicles are allowed in the tram stop blocks which alternate along Swanston Street.

And no cabs are supposed to be in any part of Swanston Street, unless it is a disability specific cab in the act of picking up or setting down a disabled passenger. (A temporary exception is being made for the hotel in Little Bourke during construction of the new Myer development)
Yet taxis are openly flouting the rules and flooding the street, putting riders at risk.

On weekdays, evenings and weekends illegal cab ranks are regularly formed along the street right alongside the parking signs forbidding their presence.

It is not so long ago that riders fought the battle against against tourist buses that were parking in Swanston Street despite being forbidden. It took the death of a rider to get them out.

The threat has reached its peak just as the City of Melbourne has almost completed the re-building of the street, with the opening of the final section in the RMIT precinct.

Increasing numbers of riders will be using Swanston now that works are completed and the warmer, longer days emerge.


Old Grumpy Liberal Men fight it out in Melbourne

United you stand divided you fall

Old Grumpy Liberal men are battling to extract revenge and the right to wear the Mayoral robes.

Liberal war horses, pollster Gary Morgan , ex-President of the Liberal Party John Elloit and disenfranchised North Carlton pharmacist and member of the Liberal Party David Nolte are campaigning against former Leader of the State Liberal Party  and incumbent Lord Mayor Robert Doyle.  All three have placed Robert Doyle last on their How-to-vote tickets. All three are pissed-off that they were not included in Robert Doyle's inner sanctum and granted access to the spoils of public office or given plum postings to internal and outside committee positions.

All three grumpy old men have enlisted the support of ALP members to help fight their campaign of revenge.

David Nolte has enlisted local ALP Carlton Branch President Richard Foster to head up his Council Team whilst Gary Morgan and John  Elliott have listed Jackie Watts.     Jackie Watts has little support within the ALP but is seen as a vote winner by the Morgan Camp in their campain of opposition to Robert Doyle.

The attack on Robert Doyle is most likely going to backfire as Liberal Party voters disown and distance themselves from all three in droves.  Disunity is the death in politics and those spearheading a campaign of opposition to the incumbent Lord Mayor will be sidelined and lose support as a result.

Tuesday, October 02, 2012

Council Divided

Preliminary Analysis of registered HTV Cards shows that a Council divided amongst thieves and a disturbing trend of voters being wooed based on race.

The expected out come of the City Council ballot is as follows
.
Team Doyle (3 positions)
Singer and John So - Melbourne Living (2 positions) 
Greens (2 positions)*
Shanahan/Chamberlin (1 position)
with a contest between Gary Morgan and David Nolte for the last position.

There is growing concern that voters are being wowed not based on policy but by race.  Whilst the Melbourne Chinese Community is divided and a fair contest. Independent candidate Moti Visa is seeking to appeal to the Indian vote (with an estimated 2,000 to 3,000 voters of Indian descent).

If voters do cast their vote on the basis of race and follow Moti Visa's HTV card which steps though Shanahan and Chamberlin's number two candidate, Roshena Dutta, before landing on Morgan/Elliot lead candidate Jackie Watts. This should  elect Watts ahead of David Nolte's  lead candidate, David Foster who would be left with what is referred to as the wasted quota. Foster has one advantage in that he holds the first position on the ballot paper but this will not be a trump card as it is in the Lord Mayors race.   The Greens stand to lose out with their second candidate to David Foster should they fail to receive more than 18% primary vote.

Stephen Mayne, who was defeated by David Nolte in the recent Melbourne State Seat by-election, is expected to poll around 2% before being excluded and having his vote distributed to top up Jackie Watts before flowing on to the Greens. If the Greens fail to win two seats then David Foster has a real possibility of creeping over the line.

There is an outside chance, unlikely, that Kevin Chamberlin's Number two candidate could be a contender for the last seat  but this is dependent on her out-polling Moti Visa and remaining in the count to collect his preferences. Moti Visa's supporters need to vote below the line and there is reduced likely-hood that they will follow his ticket.

Kevin Chamberlin has secured his election on the of a sleezy deal with Team Doyle in which they have traded support for Doyle's Lord Mayor nomination in exchange for support in the Council election. Much of the Chamnberln's gamble is dependent on Doyle having a surplus of votes to distribute. In previous elections he had none.  If Doyle pol;s three quota (30%) then their will be no spoils or surplus to hand on. It will be thanks Kevin for all the fish.

What is clear is that Team Doyle will elect two and no more than three positions on Council leaving Carl Jetter high and dry and defeated.

Preference Sweet Heart Deals - Favour Singer and Doyle cutting Shanahan out of the race

Analysis of the published preference deals tell a tale of betrayal and deceit.

Out of contention is the Greens and Brian Shanahan leaving Doyle as front runner and an outside chance for  Gary Singer/John So Jr  .

Lord Mayor

Forward Together -  Keith Rankin (LM) Grace Han (DLM): Preferences go to Robert Doyle (2) and then Shanahan (3) Shanahan will not see these preferences as they will sit with Team Doyle

Shanahan Chamberlin for Melbourne - Brian Shanahan (LM) Judy Katz (DLM) Preferences go to David Nolte (2), Keith Rankin (3) and then transfer to Team Doyle. Shanahan effectively elcting Doyle when he is eliminated.  This deal is a trade off to ensue that Keven Chamberlin is elected to Council and the Greens defeated. Shanhan has the advantage of the Donkey vote but fails to pick up preferences ahead of the Greens where it counts. He will be eliminated early in the count

Team Doyle - Robert Doyle (LM) Susan Riley (DLM): Robert Doyle is the front runner and expected to win.  he picks up the donkey vote and also preferences from Brian Shanahan (See above) his only contender now is Gary Singer and John So.  Doyle's preferences go to Brian Shanahan but he will not stay alive in teh count to see them transferred.

Morgan Elliot - Prosperity for Livibility - Gary Morgan (LM) John Eliot (DLM):  Morgan will poll below 10% Morgan and John Elliot (ex-Liberal Party President) has placed Robert Doyle last they have cut a deal with disinfected Liberal Party member David Nolte. Nolte would need to out poll Morgan in order to see his preference but he will not benefit much as Mograns preferences will not hold.  Their preferences favours the Greens and then flows to Gary Singer/John So.  Many of his supporters will not vote Greens  (Possible advantage to Singer/So

Our Melbourne - David Nolte (LM) Connie Paglianti (DLM)  Nolte has crossed preferenced to Shanahan which if Shanahan can outpoll Notle will delay his exclusion. Same applies to Nolte but neither can out-poll the Greens, Doyle or Singer. Nolte's vote eventually lands on Gary Singer giving Singer/So a clear advantage over the Greens and a contest with team Doyle

The Greens - Alison Parks (LM)  David Collis (DLM): The Greens are in a contest with Shanhan,  Nolte and Morgan. Whilst Morgan in theory favours the Greens his vote will not hold. Singer will out-poll the Greens and be transferred in the majority to Singer/So if Robert Doyle is not already elected following the transfer of Brian Shanahan's votes.

Gary Singer - John So Melbourne Living - Gary Singer (LM) John So, Jr. (DLM):  Singer is best placed in terms of the published preferences. He has honoured his preference deal to Brian Shanahan. A deal that was not receipiated. Undone at the last moment to sure up Kevin Chamberlin's election in the Council ballot.  Singer is well placed to pickup preferences from Morgan and Nolte and the Greens. He will needs to secure around 15% to 20% primary vote to remain a strong contender for second place and a possible win.

Community And Business Leadership - Bernard Ahmed (LM) Sunny Lu (DLM): Ahmed will be the second candidate eliminated after Joseph Toscano. His preferences flow to team Doyle via the Greens estimated 1% to 2% 

Put Public First - Joseph Toscano (LM) Jean Ely (DLM): Toscano is a serial candidate that polls less than 500 votes.  He will be the first excluded and will travel the field before landing on Gary Singer.



Analysis of past votes show that voters nominate and preference their first two chosen candidates and then donkey vote from the top down (Known as the Inverse Donkey Vote).   This would under normal circumstances favour Brian Shanahan but Shanhan will be excluded before he can benefit from the preference flow.  The inverse donkey vote elected Robert Doyle in 2008.  Had Peter McMullin been placed at the top of the ballot in 2008 he would have been elected instead of Robert Doyle.

Doyle as the advantage thanks to Brian Shanahan's "sweet-heart" preference deal but much depends on the pull power of John So and how much John So (Sr) is prepared to spend to help kick off his sons political carrer.

South of the Yarra ignored by City Council and media

Tyranny  of the Majority

 Independent Candidate and South Yarra Resident, Anthony van der Craats, has expressed concern that residents South of the Yarra are being ignored and unrepresented.  Southbank, St Kilda Road and South Yarra residents are located in part of the electorate that is poorly serviced by the City Council and stuck between two to three State and Federal electorates. More often than not we are ignored by all three teirs of government.

 Mr van der Craats who moved from North of the Yarra to the Southern side said part of the problem is that there is no local newspaper that covers the whole of the city and as such we are cut out of the debate and community discussion which does not include residents on the South side of the City

With most city councillors and candidates seeking election to the Melbourne City Council not living in the municipality there is little wonder why residents on the South side are ignored.

 There is little infrastructure development and and proper planning. South Yarra, Domain Road in particular is suffering as a result. The City of Melbourne Council's planning system as failed the local community.

 Instead of development that is needed we are facing increasing pressure and proposals for the establishment of bars and night clubs in what is primarily a residential precinct. "The last thing we need is another bar or night club in Domain Road".

We have lost our local butcher and local post office and lack good quaility amenities and shops. The one thing we need the most is a quaility deli and produce store all we have left is a small fruit shop and a Seven Eleven. A quality local delecatesian that can provide good cheeses, meat and produce is much needed. Instead of food we get bars and night clubs and with it the problems associated with them. Enough is enough.

Have your say: Melbourne Leader

The City Council is no longer open and transparent. Melbourne Leader

 Meetings are held behind closed doors and decisions made under delegation. Incumbent Councillors, including Green candidates, have supported the shift away from open democracy and have ignored provisions of the Local Government Act that require Council meetings to be held and open to the public.  The Councillor Forums, where most decisions are made, are held in secret contrary to the LGA. 

The Council is being run like a private corporation. There is a distinct lack of understanding of public duty and responsibility. Private interests prevail ahead of the publics interest.

Open and transparent government and community representatives that can engage the community in public debate and participation is the cornerstone to good local government.

We need a strong advocate, such as Brian Shanahan and Kevin Chamberlin, who can restore balance, openness and community representation.

Anthony van der Craats, 
Independent unaligned Candidate. 
www.Melbcity.net.au

Monday, October 01, 2012

VEC: Candidate Statement and use of common Acronyms rejected by Stalinist Electoral Commission

The VEC rejected the publication of independent Candidate, Anthony van der Craats statement. Mr. Van der Craats had submitted a candidate statement using the acronyms JET SET and TER.  the VEC claimed the acronyms, which referred to Councillors travel account, was a reference to Carl Jetter, a candidate in the election standing under Team Doyle. The rejection comes amidst a number of concerns and complaints of overhanded State polices that are designed to restrict and prevent independence and individuality of candidates seeking election.   The publication of a candidates statements plays a significant role in voters choice.

"A candidate should be free to make a statement as they think fit and it is not the role of the electoral commission to dumb down or limit what is said and how it is presented" Mr Anthony van der Craats said "We live in a democracy not a Stalinist state".

The term JET is an acronym for Junior Executive Travel, SET refers to Senior Executive Travel and  TER Travel Expense Report.  All closely related to the context of Councillor Travel Expenses.

The VEC have crossed the line from administrator to participant. What's next? If we expressed concern at the level of noise generated by a Singer in Bourke Street  or opposition to the use of Councillor Visa Cards or included the statement "So What".  Is it within the realm of the VEC to rule the statement invalid?   

Independent unaligned candidates are at a distinct disadvantage. Voters wishing to support them have to cast a vote below-the-line for all candidates and are only entitled to publish one How-to-vote ticket, where as Group voters have the advantage of registering two Group voting tickets and voters only tick one box above-the-line. 


Mr van der Craats original statement (Rejected by the VEC)


www.melbcity.blogspot.com    Independent “Ungrouped” Candidate *  South Yarra, Resident of Melbourne since 1985 * Senior Systems Analyst (ICT) and Migration Agent * Life member of the National Trust of Australia *  Community Activist *  Member of the Australian Labor Party.       Issues: Open and transparent government, good governance and effective community consultation; The need for electoral reform and review of external boundaries creating a Greater City of Melbourne; Putting an end to the rorts, misuse and abuse of “JET set TER” Councillor expenses used to promote  personal business interests;  It’s time to  scrap the Lord Mayor’s Limo and stop the provision of “free booze” to Councillors paid for by ratepayers - No more drunk Councillors or inebriated Lord Mayors;  Reduced costs to business and residents alike.  *** Please vote below the line allocating preferences and support for unaligned candidates ***    email:  anthony@melbcity.net.au  tel: 04033 78 111 << more information www.melbcity.net.au 

 

Greens sidelined in sleazy preference deals

The knives were out in what was claimed to be the morning of betrayal.

The Greens have struck up a deal with Liberal pollster Gray Morgan and  ex-Liberal party President John Elliott in an effort to out-poll lead community candidate Brian Shanahan in the fold up of preferences.

The sleazy preference deal will not help the Greens and Morgan cannot deliver preferences.  Many of Morgan;s supporters will back the Civic Group - Incumbent leader Robert Doyle.

Serial candidate Stephen Mayne was present trying to suck up to the Greens,  Mayne is unlikely to survive the count and instead will help direct preferences to the Greens in the lower house (Council) election. The fact is Stephen Mayne has no support base and therefore will not influence the outcome. He is just a tool and a puppet used by the Greens to gain a few extra hundred votes .

Mayne's arch enemy and road block, David Nolte, also a Liberal Party Candidate, is seeking revenge on the Doyle team placing the Greens ahead of Doyle who is last on his Ballot Paper.  The Greens are unlikely to survive the preference distribution.  They have been placed behind Doyle on community candidate Brian Shanahan's ticket placing the Lord Mayor election out of reach.

There still remains three contenders for the Mayoral Robes.  Incumbent Robert Doyle faces a contest between Gary Singer and Brian Shanahan. Both Shanahan and Singer have crossed preferences.   Singer is betting on the John So factor. He has nominated John So's son as his deputy Lord Mayor hoping to cash in on the good will and recognition of former popular Lord Mayor, John So.  It is unclear as to how well this tactic will perform. If it does attract voter support it will affect both camps.

What is clear, the Greens having struck up a deal with Morgan and Elliot cannot claim the moral high ground and have demonstrated once and for all that they are not pro-Melbourne community or really interested in environmental outcomes,  just power.

The Greens have been cut out from the Lord Mayoral Race with Doyle in the prime spot and the only candidate in a position to win against him is Brian Shanahan (the only rider is if Gary Singer can strike up a tune and serenade the electorate with John So, Junior - "We're putting the band back together for a revival").  - Let the games begin!

Our tip: Vote Shanahan Chamberlin for a true and effective local voice.