Friday, February 01, 2008
The Code of SilenceThe Road to China block by a wall of bureaucracy
In a surprise move Greens Councillor, Fraser Brindley, has played lip service top the notion that the documents should be published. Do not expect Brindely to do anything other then comment from a far. Unlike his predecessor Brindley's commitment to open and transparent government is not that strong. He does not have a good track record on holding them to account. Brindley is more noted for his efforts to avoid open public disclosure and previously referred Council reports for consideration behind closed doors at an illegal Councillors forum meeting. The meeting you have when your not having a meeting. Under the terms of the Local Government all meetings of council must be open to the public and only items declared confidential are discussed in closed session.
The reports consider by the Council in the Councillor only briefings are not confidential and should have been discuss in open session.
Likewise the correspondence between the Council and the Chinese embassy should also be made public.
Hopefully the Age will appeal against the Council's refusal to provide copies of documents.
Council's China link letters blocked
February 1, 2008
Source: The Age
MELBOURNE City Council has refused to release correspondence with the Chinese consulate, claiming the letters are exempt from freedom of information requests because of diplomatic immunity.
Lord Mayor John So, who has a history of close ties to the Chinese Government, said yesterday he had not interfered in the decision to keep all council correspondence — both to and from the Chinese consulate in Melbourne — confidential.
The Age last year requested, under freedom of information laws, all correspondence between the council and the consulate.
But the council's lawyers have refused.
They argue that the Chinese consulate is immune from freedom of information laws because of the "inviolability" articles of the Vienna Convention.
These say that all official correspondence of consulates can be shielded from scrutiny.
Acting council chief executive Geoff Lawler said the council had asked the Chinese consulate if it was happy to release documents to The Age.
"The Chinese consulate objected on the grounds that they were exempt under the Vienna Convention," he said.
But city councillor Fraser Brindley said the council had made a mistake refusing to release the documents.
"A council talking to a consulate shouldn't be confidential," he said. "This is another in a long list of incidents where John So's doing what the Chinese Government wants done. "Is his first service to the Chinese Government or to Melbourne?"
Last year, Cr So used his numbers on the council to quash a proposed Town Hall reception for the Falun Gong movement, which is banned in China.
The Chinese consulate did not return calls from The Age yesterday.
Saturday, February 10, 2007
VEC avoids accountability and disclosure Detailed results of the State Election missing
The Victorian Electoral Commission in administering the FOI request has possible breached the provisions of the Victorian Electoral Act and or Privacy Act. A complaint associated with the Victorian Electoral Commissions handling of the application has been forwarded tho The Victorian Privacy Commission for consideration and review.
Access to the information requested is still outstanding.
The Victorian Electoral Commission went to extra-ordinary length and considerable expense in printing out in hard copy most of the information that was provide as opposed to just copying the information and forwarding it in electronic format. Why? we fail to understand but I am sure a few more trees died in vein as a result. We accept no responsibility for the VEC actions in this respect as we had anticipated and expected that the information would be provided in electronic format. Some people would be forgiven in thinking that the VEC provided the information in hard copy format in order to prevent its distribution, collation and data analysis. That might not be far off the mark. It is difficult to say but efficient and cost saving it was not. As the information was sent to the wrong address we have requested that the VEC re-forward copies of their response in electronic format this time. Saving time and money.
The Victorian Electoral Commission had responded to the FOI request in part only they failed to provided copies of all the information requested.
Missing are:
Copies of below the line preference data was provided free of charge during the 1999, 2002 an 2004 Melbourne City Council Elections. This information is readily available and would be no more then 1mb for each electorate and would take approx. 2 mins to copy per file and this information should be published on the Victorian Electoral Commission's web site.
Without access to the below the line data files it is impossible to effectively scrutinise of verify the results of the election.
The below the line preference data is a public document and precedence has been set in a ruling of the Victorian Civil Appeals Tribunal requiring that this information be made available.
3. Copies of polling centers return summary results information for the legilsative Council (Upper-house) - similar information detailing polling place results in relation to lower house electorates was published by the VEC on their Internet web site.
The Victorian electoral commission has claimed that the cost of providing this information would be in excess of $600.00 which is very dubious and highly questionable.
The information is stored in electronic format and the cost of copying that information would be less then $2.00.
Polling place data for the Legislative Council is normally available and published on election night and updated through the count.
In the 2006 State Election the Victorian Electoral Commission failed to make this information available instead they only provided an electorate wide summary only. (The AEC provides senate results statistics broken down to polling places)
Access to the polling place summary data is fundamental in providing a check and balance as to the number of ballot papers issued and returned.
There were a number of substantial errors recorded during the conduct of the count of the Victorian State Election that had this information been readily available could have and should have been avoided. A quick summary of the polling place returns should have altered the Victorian Electoral Commission that a number of ballot papers had been missing or overstated prior to the distribution of any preferences. This information is still outstanding.
4. The Victorian Electoral Commission has provided limited information on the certification of software used to conduct the Victorian State Election count. Copies of certification certificates have been provided (but not yet received - due to the VEC mistake in addressing their response) for the electronic 'Kiosk' voting centres and the algorithm used in the calculation of the proportional representation results.
Missing is the detailed supporting certification documentation, reports and certification of the actual software related to the data-entry, front end, data storage and reporting software that utilises the algorithm used. Either the software used by the Victorian Electoral Commission has not been fully certified of the Victorian Electoral Commission has withheld access to this information.
In summary
The Victorian Electoral Commission again is seeking to avoid open and public disclose of the detailed results of the 2006 Victorian State Election.
A number of serious errors in the counting of the election have occurred and questions related to the discrepancy in the number of total votes record between the preliminary count and the recount in Western Metropolitan region have north been fully explained or verifiable based on the public documentation provided.
We are informed that copies of the below the line data files were not made available to scrutineers.
There is a discrepancy of over 450 ballot papers between the preliminary count and the recount. Without access to the polling place return data and the below the line preference data files, as requested, it is impossible to verify the results of the election .
It is fundamental that our public elections are open and transparent and subject to independent review and analysis.
With the utilisation of electronic computer based technology all relevant information and data files must be readily available to scrutineers and the public.
One can only ask
"WHY IS THE VICTORIAN ELECTORAL COMMISSION RELUCTANT TO MAKE THIS INFORMATION AVAILABLE THAT THEY ARE PREPARED TO GO TO SUCH EXTENTS TO AVOID DISCLOSURE AND ACCOUNTABILITY".
The actions of the Chief Electoral Commissioner and the Victorian Electoral Commission continues to bring 2006 Victorian State Election into disrepute.
Thursday, December 21, 2006
FOI Application required to obtain detailed election results for State Election VEC brought to account
The conduct of the election undertaken by the Victorian Electoral Commission (VEC) was a shame and has brought Victoria in to disrepute.
Nick Economu, election analyst and political commentator, has described the conduct of the count as a "farcical". That was putting it mildly. We would say highly unprofessional if not incompetent, lacking in openness and transparency. Information crucial to the conduct of the election was denied and the VEC continues to avoid public scrutiny and review by failing to publish the various count sheets and detailed preference data.
We were constantly being told that the software used in computerized vote counting system had been certified and that safeguards were in place to avoid and limit mistakes in a data-entry. That turned out to be false. As history often proves man is not infallible and the VEC most certainly has failed to live up to the expectations and requirement for an open and transparent election.
Rob Hulls, Victoria's Attorney General and Minister responsible for the Victorian Electoral Commission and the Freedom of Information Act, stated in his annual FOI report: "The existence of the FOI Act should not mean that the formal process provided under it is the only means of obtaining access to documents or information of an agency. "
Section 123 of the Victorian Electoral Act 2002 states:
123. Election information
(1) The number of first preference votes given for each candidate and the details of distribution of preference votes must be available from the office of the Commission.
The refusal of the VEC to publish this information, as requested, is an abuse of the system and denial of open and transparent elections.
VEC receipt of payment for FOI application fee
--- Copy of FOI request delieverd to to the VEC today ---
Thursday December 21, 2006
Sue Lang
Manager Communication, Education and Research Branch
Information Officer
Victorian Electoral Commission
Re: Freedom of Information Request
Dear Sue
Pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act, I wish to request the following information -
- Victorian State Election November 2006
1.1. Copies of all count sheets in respect to all electorates for the Victorian Legislative Assembly and Victorian Legislative Council
1.2. Copies of all recorded electronic data files detailing the ballot papers preference allocations used to determine the results of each election for the Victorian Legislative Assembly and Legislative Council
1.3. Copies of all polling place returns showing the number of ballot papers issued and the number of first preferences allocated for each candidate for the Legislative Assembly and the Legislative Council - Copies of all certification documents related to the software used in the conduct of the Victorian State election used in the tabulation and calculation of the elections results.
I have previously requested this information, to which the Victorian Electoral Commission to date has failed to respond.
The above, as requested information is a public document and should be readily available to members of the public for independent review and assessment.
It is in the public interest that this information is made available and that the results and the conduct of the election are open and transparent.
In addition, as this information is in the public interest and should be readily available to public, I request that the fee for this Freedom of Information Application be waived. However, in case you do not allow this, I enclose the required $21.50.
I draw you attention to the following:
Victorian Civil Appeals Tribunal in 1999 (van der Craats v City of Melbourne [2000] VCAT 447 (29 January 2000) VICTORIAN CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL General List No. 1999/057919)
I request that the above information be provided without delay.
In the event that the Victorian Electoral Commission refuses in the first instance to provide this information I request that immediate internal review undertaken and if required I am prepared to have this matter refered to the Victorian State Parliament, Victorian State Ombudsman and the Victorian Civil Appeals Tribunal for review.
Should you require further I can be contacted via return email or telephone (03) 9016 3654
Yours faithfully
Anthony van der Craats
Wednesday, March 01, 2006
Disclosing the cost of administration Council's reluctance to publish public information is in need of review
The Herald Sun reported that the city of Whitehorse and Maribyrnong refused to make available information pertaining to the disclosure of Senior Management's salaries packages. under the provisions of the Local Government regulations details of salary pakages and remuneration over 100,000 per year must be recorded in a register which in turn must be made available for public inspection. inspection of the register is a right of all members of the public and there is no basis in which the information can be withheld.
With the advent of the internet there is no reason, technical or administrative why this information can not and should not be made available via the internet. Appropriate security and validation checks can be provided for.
Clearly the State Government needs to review its legislative requirements to ensure that all public documentation and information is readily available via the internet. there is no excuse for the petty games of avoidance by trying to restrict access to this information by making it difficult to access.
What do they have to hide and what gain is there from maintaining such an inefficient system.
Tuesday, February 28, 2006
Hiding the count Victorian Electoral Commission refuses to publish details of 2005 Municipal Elections
With the introduction of electronic computer based counting systems access to this information is vital to maintaining an honest, open and transparent electoral system.
The City of Melbourne in 1999 and 2001 tried unsuccessfully to prevent the release of this information. The Melbourne City Council spent over $60,000, acting under the misguided direction of Alison Lyons, Melbourne City Council's Governance Officer in attempt to deny open and transparent scrutiny of the conduct of the Council's elections. This matter was the subject of a successful appeal to the Victorian Civil Appeals Tribunal in 1999 (van der Craats v City fo Melbourne [2000] VCAT 447 (29 January 2000) VICTORIAN CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL General List No. 1999/057919)
The ruling of the tribunal requiring the City of Mlebourne and the Australian Electoral Commisison to release this information was made without reservation and was a clear indication that specious the argument put forward by the City of Melbourne was lacking substance and merit.
Why has the Victorian Electoral Commission refused to publish this information?
The VEC's argument has no legal or administrative basis. Copies of the ballot prefence data file should be readily aviailable to the public and should form part of the declartion of the results of the election.
This issue has been back and forth with the Victorian Electoral Commission on a number of occasions.
Clearly the Victorian Electoral Commission in refusing to provide Mr Quick the information requested raises serious questions pertaining the conduct of Elections.
The need to provide open and transparent electoral procedures is important if public confidence in our electoral system is to be maintained. With the introduction of proportional representation in the election of the Legislative Council this issue needs to be resolved well before November State Election.
Thursday, February 09, 2006
Council's avoidance and censorship Finance Committee minutes confirms Councillors' refusal to publish reports that are critical of the Council
6. GENERAL BUSINESS (agenda item 6)
6.1 Response to Correspondence Received by Mr Anthony van der Craats
The Chair referred to the matter previously raised in relation to the correspondence of 4 February 2006 (which incorporated information contained in correspondence dated 24 December 2005) 3rd, 2nd and 1st February 2006 received from Mr Anthony van der Craats. The Chair, Cr Shanahan, moved the following motion: “That the Finance and Corporate Performance Committee note the correspondence and include in quarterly travel reports to Committee a register of in-bound travel funded by Council.” Cr Snedden seconded the motion.
The motion was put and carried unanimously.
Copies of correspondence was circulated to Councillors but the Council in a deliberate attempt of avoidance refused to publish the reports and make them available to the public. WHY?
Committee chairman Councillor Brian Shanahan has failed to provide an explanation. Missing in the documentation and deliberations of the Committee are recommendations for the City of Melbourne to publish expenses related to in-house catering and the cost associated with the Lord Mayor and Deputy Lord Mayor's Council funded limousines. Clearly the Council does not want this information made public - what is it the are trying to hide that they go to extraorindary lengths to avoid?
Whilst the City Council has agreed to publish in-bound travel expenses funded by the Council the full costs of in-bound missions will not be disclosed with the cost of travel being a small part of the overall cost of in-bound missions.
Why did the Council agree to publish limited information on in-bound missions but refused to publish travel costs associated the Lord Mayor and Deputy Lord Mayor's Limousines and Council's in-house catering bill?
The City of Melbourne continues to deny the public access to information in what is seen as an ongoing abuse of process.
The public have a right to know the full costs and details of council expenditure. The question that is outstanding is the City of Melbourne still intending to produce a report on the full cost of In-bound Missions and will that report be tabled in an open and public meeting?
Greens Councillor Fraser Brindley in December 2005 moved a motion that the in-bound mission report as requested by Cr Snedden be referred to a secret 'illegal' meeting of Council behind closed (Shame Fraser Shame). The holding of secret meetings is contrary to the provisions of the Local Government Act and the principle of open and transparent governance which require that all public documents and deliberations of Council be made in open public meetings.
Whilst it has been noted that Greens Councillor Fraser Brindley has expressed regret in moving the motion in december he never the less has failed to re-address this issue and continues, along with other Councillors, to support the suppression of reports and documents that expose the true cost of governance of the City of Melbourne. Is this the quaility of Governance we can expect form the Greens should they be elected to State Parliament? Given their current performance I do not think they will make it.
The report and recommendations that have been withheld by the City Council outlined a number of concerns related to errors and omissions in the Council's published data and included recommendations protect the integrity of the Council's financial registers against possible fraud and deception.
The Council Travel Register in its current form is an electronic whiteboard open to abuse and misuse with staff able to alter, remove or delete information without detection.
The report recommended that Council include a Record Id number (Which is normal professional practice) to assist in the proper audit of the register information and to help prevent misuse, abuse and possible fraud. Previous copies of the Travel Register have been modified to remove undisclosed expenses related to former Councillor Anthony Nicholson's St Petersburg 'mid summer' tour, with $8,000.00 still missing from the published Councillor expense statements.
The City Council continue to avoid accountability as opposed to accepting responsibility by talking action to prevent ongoing misuse and abuse of the Council administration who are engaged in a excerise of cover-up and denial. Until they address the issue in a professional and proper manner the problems identified will not disappear. Advodiance and denial is not the answer.
Tuesday's Finance and Corporate Performance (sic) committee meeting also failed to publish and consider items of correspondence in relation to item 5.7 "Council's Long Stay Car Park Levy" and its "Transport policy".
If the Melbourne City Council can not demonstrate its ability to self-govern and continues to avoided addressing this issue in a proper and responsible manner then the only other alternative is to refer the issue to the State office of the Auditor General and Ombudsman for review and further consideration.
Wednesday, February 01, 2006
City without cars (except LM000)Melbourne City Council should lead by example and scrape the LM's Limo and close down its Car Parks
We would all like to have a cleaner environment and better public transport but the Lord Mayor and the City Council should practice what it preaches before giving the sermon.
If the Lord Mayor is serious and not just grandstanding and attention seeking as a means of covering up for his for lack of policies and direction for Melbourne, he should consider first getting rid of the Lord Mayor (LM0001) and deputy Lord Mayor's Limousines which according to information obtained under FOI in 2004 was costing City ratepayer well over $180,000.00 per year ($100,000 for the Lord Mayors driver alone).
The City of Melbourne maintains a fleet a few hundred cars and continues to offer staff remuneration benefits packages that include car lease agreements - they should go also.
Seriously what is the City going to do? Close down all the car parks it has so diligently encouraged to be constructed over the last 15 years? Maybe the Council should set an example and close its car-park in Little Collins Street first?
Tuesday, December 13, 2005
Feasting on the ratepayer
The Lord mayor is said to spend up big holding regular State like functions wineing and dining the many visitors and guests to our city.
Councillors and senior staff enjoy a full course meal every meeting and staff regularly serve light meals, snacks and drinks at the numerous functions and seminars held within the town hall. It makes the State Parliament dinning room look like a tuck shop.
Senior Council staff also add to the bill by ordering takeaway, or dine-out at expensive restaurants when it suits, picking up the tab on the corporate credit card.
One staff member put on the Council credit card the cost of $100/person for a night out for the entire delegation on one of the Council's many overseas junkets. Because the cost was allocated to the staff members account the amount spent did not show up on the Councillors' expense statement. Cleaver creative accounting recipes in how to cook the books.
There are many Municipal Councils who would die to have access to half of the Council's catering bill - just to meet necessary community expenses let alone the luxury entertainment enjoyed by staff and councillors down at town hall.
Some Councillors have been reported as saying the quality of the in-house catering is not to their likening and the food just goes to waste left untouched on the plate until deposited in the bin
There are homeless people on the streets of Melbourne who go without a meal and are lucky if they can afford the cost of a Big Mac.
We have requested the Council provide detailed cost breakdown of the Council's in-house catering bill but to date have not received any response to our request.
Surely the Council maintains an account of this expenditure in its financial analysis, if not then why not, if yes then publish the details. Show us the bill and do not forget the tips and cost of alcohol.
It would appear that the only way to obtain information on the expenditure of the City Council is via Freedom of Information. This is a clear abuse of process as Council have an obligation to make this information available without the need to apply under FoI.
As s0on as we get a meaningful reply to our request we will publish it for all to see but don't hold back your appetite waiting... we expect it will be a long wait before it is served.
Tuesday, November 22, 2005
FoI: City of Melbourne In-house Catering Expenses
To the Freedom of Information Officer
City of Melbourne
Swanston Street
MELBOURNE VIC 3000
Dear Sir/Madam
Pursuant to the Victorian Freedom of Information Act I wish to request the following information.
1. A detailed monthly summary report of all in-house catering expenses provided to staff and Councillors covering the period from December 1, 2004 to the current date.
This report where possible should provide a breakdown of expenses occurred by department for each calendar month and include the cost associated with the provision of alcohol and refreshments.
If available a breakdown of costs for each individual councillor
I note that in-house catering expenses are not included or listed in the published Councillor expense statements.
As the information requested is of public interest, I request that the Council waiver the application fee required.
Should you require further information I can be contacted via return email
Yours faithfully
Anthony van der Craats
melbcity@gmail.com
Web site: http://melbournecitycouncil.blogspot.com/
FoI: City of Melbourne Travel Register
To the Freedom of Information Officer
City of Melbourne
Swanston Street
MELBOURNE VIC 3000
Dear Sir/Madam
Pursuant to the Victorian Freedom of Information Act I wish to request the following information.
1. Copy in electronic format of the City of Melbourne's Travel Register covering the period from December 1, 2004 to the current date.
The Council Travel Register was previously available and published by the City of Melbourne on it's internet site.
The previous Council had requested the Travel Register be published on the Council's Internet site as part of its ongoing commitment to open and transparent Governance. It was the intention that the information published would cover the term of the then current council and that the information would be continued to be updated and published on an ongoing basis into the future including future Councils.
The Council administration, in what is considered a cynical move to avoid accountability, has since removed this information for publication without first seeking the authority, consent of resolution of the incumbent elected Council.
The Travel Register is a public document required to be maintained by the Council under the provisions of the Victorian Local Government Act.
The Victorian Parliament believes that this information is important and must be readily available to the public.
A number of request made to the Council seeking the reinstatement and publication of the updated Travel Register on the Council's Internet site has not been addressed with the Council and it's administration failing to respond to numerous correspondence.
The cost of publishing this information is minimal and requires minimal to no additional resources.
The failure of the City of Melbourne Council to address this issue and to publish this information as requested has brought the Council into disrepute in that it is seen as a blatant attempt to avoid disclosure and public accountability contrary to the principles of open and transparent government.
The Council has spent more money and resources in avoidance then the cost of compliance.
In the absence of the Council responding to previous requests I now seek access to this information under the provisions of FoI legislation.
I request that this information be made available with out delay
Further as this information is in the public's interest I request that the Council wavier the FoI application fee required.
Should you require further information I can be contacted via return email
Yours faithfully
Anthony van der Craats
melbcity@gmail.com
Web site: http://melbournecitycouncil.blogspot.com/
cc Media