Thursday, October 11, 2012

Day Three: All ballots posted

The VEC should have posted all ballot papers by Today. They had dispatched them in three lots over the last three days.  Any voter who has not received a ballot paper in the mail should contact the Returning Officer and request a new ballot be sent out.

To date I have been door knocked by one party only (Gary Singer), I have received a letter box drop from Robert Dole and the Greens. (The Greens card was printed on one solid paper one side only (So much for their concern on the environment)

Analysis of past voting trends indicate that most voters having chosen a Candidate or team to support will vote according to the team/candidate's recommendations published in the candidates information booklet. In 2004 only 9% voted below the line of those a vast majority still followed the general group recommendations.  Below-the-line voters tend to stick with the team they originally had chosen, changing the order of candidates but then preference more of less the same as the group vote. Of those that differ a majority (All up 3%-4% ) "Inverse Donkey" vote filling in the ballot from the top down left to right.  Because the spread of below-the-line votes favours no particular candidate and they tend to stay within the group chosen the Below-the-line vote is not expected to have any significance in the outcome of the election in terms of the group vote. Of course it does effect independent ungrouped candidates whoes supporters have to vote below-the-line.

In the end it is only a question of magnitude. The most significant question is what percentage of the overall vote will Team Doyle, the Greens and  Gary Singer's group attract. All three are in the hunt for two or more places (Team Doyle is hoping to secure over 40% of the vote and absolute control of the City Council.  Both the Greens and Gary Singer group are pushing to secure 20%.

The Greens are assisted by outsider former Templestowe Councillor and serial candidate, Stephen Mayne. Stephen Mayne is expected to attract less than 3%-4%  and then top up the Greens to give them a second seat.  The Greens who are expected to poll around 14%-16% surplus must remain above Mayne's primary vote. The odds are in the Greens favour to out-poll Mayne who is effectively is by default a feeder candidate for the Greens, part of the payoff for Greens preferences in the Melbourne State Seat by-election.

Given that the campaign has failed to attract any serious media coverage we are down grading our estimate for minor candidates and upping the estimate for the main players.


Roshena Dutta
The prospect of Team Doyle polling over 40% of the ticket votes is alarming and if it comes true would spell a period of discontent and further decline in open and transparent governance in Melbourne.

It is for this reason that we advocate that voters place Team Doyle and the Greens last and have chosen to support community based candidates listed on the Shanahan Chamberlin ticket.. Young Lawyer/Community activist Roshena Dutta is certainly worthy of your support.

Please vote below-the-line and remember to number all candidates in order of your choice.Ballot papers must be received by the returning Officer no later than 6PM Friday October 26

Wednesday, October 10, 2012

Gary Singer: Knocks South Yarra - Big Turn Off

Gary Singer's team of paid door knockers are out and about in South Yarra.  He is the only candidate that canvases this side of the Yarra.

Biggest problem Singer has is his decision to preference the preference the Greens seconded on his how to vote card. - A big turn off in this part of the city. Singer's official book vote places Brian Shanahan in second place.

Singer can not win the Lord Mayorship - even with John So (jr) as his deputy. Supporting the Greens has just made it that much harder and provided another reason not to vote Singer So - Melbourne Living.

Tuesday, October 09, 2012

Ballot Me: Voting Begins in Earnest

The Victorian Electoral Commission begins posting ballot papers out today.  Ballot papers will be posted in three lots over the next three days with ballot papers to the housing estates delivered by hand. from past experiences many of the ballot papers delivered to the Housing Estatesare discarded or left lying around or open to misuse and abuse by those seeking to manipulate the vote by questionable means. (This is a problem with postal ballots in that there is no check or balance to ensure that the vote is sent in from the voters as intended.)

Most voters will send in their return vote within a day of receiving their ballot papers, others will wait until the last week. Their also is a large number of votes that arrive late.  Neighbouring municipalities are holding an attendance vote on Saturday October 27.  This creates a lot of confusion as the Melbourne ballot ends the day before. Voters who are use to voting on a Saturday and hear reports of other municipalities voting on the Saturday are caught out and their votes are discarded.  If they fail to return their vote they are subject to a fine.

This makes it some what limiting for the local communities that hold a town hall style meet the candidates meetings next week when many voters have already cast their ballot.

Our suggestion is to vote early.  Votes can be dropped off at the Town Hall or sent back via the return paid envelope.  Please remember to place your ballot in the inner envelope and sign the outer detachable flap.

More information on how-to-vote

Saturday, October 06, 2012

Bicycling Melbourne vs Road Safety. What do you the commuter think?

Do Melbourne bicycling lanes work or are they a risk to public safety and road users in general?

We have seen a massive increase in the number of bicycling lanes throughout the city and there is growing concern that they are not working and poorly planned. Major traffic routes have been compromised with lanes reduced to single file, city congestion is made worst. Many bike lanes are under utilized and there are better alternative routes. 

There has been no consultation or review.  The City planners are quick to paint lines and lay down green ashfelt in an effort top create Km of bike lanes so that they can add to the statistics that allow Melbourne to claim they are bike friendly, but are they safe for cyclists? 

Bicycle lobby groups such as BUG and Bicycle Victoria, funded by government grants, push for more and more bike paths through out the city. But there has been no comrehensive study ro review or where Melbourne is heading.  The bike paths are hinder traffic movement and create a false sense of safety.  Bikes often over take cars on the left causing potential serious accidents as cars try to navigate the city streets.

The City traffic management plans makes no provisions for motorbikes or scooters?  Many of the bicycle lanes could be shared by commuters during peak hour avoiding the need for motobikes and scooters to lane split.  Many bike paths are better located on side streets where there is no traffic.

We need a rethink of where our Bike paths are taking us. 

Tell us what you think.  BUG has refused to publish out reply to their survey so we want to ask you, residents and visitors of the City what you think? 

It is time to take back our street.

Friday, October 05, 2012

Team Doyle: Power Corrupts and Absolute Power Corrupts Absolutly

As the saying goes 

 "Absolute Power Corrupts Absolutely"


The City of Melbourne election is a question of absolute power being held in the hands of one group.  If Robert Doyle, as expected, is returned to office there is a real chance that he may also secure four of the City Councillor positions giving the Lord Mayor an absolute majority on the City Council.

If Team Doyle manage to win 40% or more of the vote in the Council "C9" ballot then Doyle would have control of 6 out of the 11 members that make up the City Council (The Lord Mayor, Deputy Lord Mayor and nine Councillors)

Incumbent Lord Mayor Robert Doyle has cut a deal with Brian Shanahan securing a preference swap ensuring the election of Kevin Chamberlain in exchange for support electing Robert Doyle in the Lord Mayor "Leadership" race. This deal rightfully cuts Greens candidate Ms Parks out of race but in the process also removes Brian Shanahan's chances of winning. Shanahan's chances of winning were removed when Liberal Members Gary Morgan and John Elliot cut a deal and exchanged preferences with the Greens Party. (A deal that will backfire on the Morgan ticket and is likely to favour Robert Doyle and his team).


It is in the best interest of the City and democracy that voters consider alternative choices and vote below-the-line putting Team Doyle last.

Robert Doyle (former Leader of State Liberal Party ) is opposed by other Liberal members standing for election.  Ken Ong, Gary Morgan and John  Elliot (Former Liberal Party State President has placed Robert Doyle last on their how to vote cards behind the Greens candidate)

 
Even facing a significant community backlash Robert Doyle remains in poll position to win the seat and could secure more than 40% of the vote which would see incumbent Councillor Carl Jetter returned to office.  Carl Jetter has been relegated to the hot seat and should Team Doyle not get 40% or more votes he will be ousted from office in this election.  Jetter has come under fire for being the most expensive City Councillor with his claimed expenses and junkets far exceeding other City Councillors

Ballot papers will be posted from October 9th to 11th and MUST be returned to the Returning Officer prior to 6PM on Friday October 26, 2012

BUG me not

Bicycle Users Group (BUG) Spokesperson, Nik Dow, accused of bias in the organsitaions publication and assessment of Candidate responses to their survey. Mr van der Craats, Independent Candidate in the City of Melbourne Municipal Election, said that he had replied to BUG's survey request and even though he had done so the organisation failed to make mention or publication of the reply.

In a wrongly worded letter Mr Dow claimed Mr van der Craats had not replied.  "This is false. Copies of my response was forwarded to Mr Dow via return email on September 28 and published on my blog" http://melbournecitycouncil.blogspot.com.au/2012/09/bug-survey.html


Mr Dow's reply dated October 4, 2012



Hi, sorry but you didn't respond to our questionnaire, and that is what we stated on our website.  

Regards,

CBDWeb
Nik Dow
Office: 03 9948 4039
 
6/165 Flinders Lane
 
Melbourne

Melbourne's Electoral System Seriously Flawed

Melbourne's electoral system is seriously flawed an in need of urgent review.

The system in place provides an unfair disadvantage to unaligned  independent candidates and the method of calculating the surplus transfer value and distribution of preferences is tainted and not accurate.

Mr van der Craats, who is running as an unaligned candidate said "that the above-the-line voting system should be scrapped and the method of counting the votes revised to address the anomalies in the system that make the system unfair".

Voters who wish to support  independent candidates or those that are not included on group tickets have to vote below-the-line. Above-the-line voters in most cases do not know where their votes or preferences are allocated or aware of the impact they have on the outcome of the election. A team or party vote locks in voters preferences which are then allocated according to the groups ticket.

The City of Melbourne is the only Municipality in Victoria that uses an above-the-line-voting system

As a team vote is able to be directed this provides an unfair advantage in the preference deals that decide the election. Un-grouped candidates are placed at the bottom of the ballot paper and denied the same rights as ticket votes in that voters have to vote below-the-line to cast a first preference vote for them. 

Most candidates running on group tickets have little to no chance of being elected and are only listed to bolster the groups appearance or to direct preferences to support other candidates.  A lead candidate on a team ticket can be elected with less than half a quota (>5% of the total vote) where an un-grouped independent candidate would require 9% or more below-the-line primary votes.

Melbourne's Council election is already decided as a result of predetermined preference deals. It is a question of magnitude and only 11 candidates are placed to have a chance of being elected.

Victoria's voting system is additionally flawed by the way in which the vote is counted.  The system of "proportional representation"and the method of calculating the surplus transfer value (The number of votes that a candidate receives that is over the 10% quota)  is not proportional. Ticket/Party votes are inflated in value at the expense of  minor parties and independent candidates.

The system used is, at best, semi-proportional and is not accurate.

Add to this technical issues related to the distribution of preferences from excluded candidates where votes are segmented and distributed in such a manner that they do not apply equally to all votes.

The principle that a a vote for an excluded candidate should be distributed in order of the voters preference as if the excluded candidate had not stood does not apply to Local Government elections. Votes skip candidates and are allocated to other candidates at a higher value than they would otherwise be had they been distributed according to the order of preference indicated by the voter. The system in use is akin to dealing from the bottom of the deck and giving higher value to some votes at the expense of others.  These distortions in the way we count the vote came about as a result of trying to ease the manual counting of votes. With the use of computer-based technology there is no justification or need to maintain the flaws in the way our votes are counted.  


If we calculated financial dividends the way Victoria calculates the vote our financial system would collapse overnight with a loss of confidence.  



In addition: The method of filling causal vacancies by count-back is also flawed in that the system does not include votes that retain a value and are left unused on the table. In the City of Melbourne count-back that was held last year over 6000 unallocated votes were ignored and voters disenfranchised.  The wrong candidate was elected to fill the casual vacancy. 

Successive Labor and Liberal Government's have failed to review the system in place and address these issues. 

The Victorian Parliament's "Electoral Matters Committee" has responsibility and oversight of Victoria's local government electoral system.  whilst they have reviewed the State election they have not reviewed the system as it applies to Local Government.

Anthony van der Craats is the National Secretary and a Life member of the Proportional Representation Society of Australia

Wednesday, October 03, 2012

So What?: Analysis based on a Singer John So revival

In this analysis we have extrapolated an increase in the Singer John  So Melbourne Living at the expense of Morgan and Nolte's Tickets to give the Singer - So team a second Councillor position.  The loser being the Greens



Elected Candidate Group
1  LOUEY, Kevin TEAM DOYLE
2  ONG, Ken MELBOURNE LIVING
3  OKE, Cathy THE GREENS
4  WOOD, Arron TEAM DOYLE
5  PINDER-MORTIMER, Beverley TEAM DOYLE
6  WATTS, Jackie MORGAN ELLIOTT- PROSPERITY FOR LIVEABILITY
7  CHAMBERLIN, Kevin SHANAHAN CHAMBERLIN FOR MELBOURNE
8  FOSTER, Richard OUR MELBOURNE
9  PAGANO, Carlo MELBOURNE LIVING 


Percentage Group Name
5.5% OUR MELBOURNE
3.5% STEPHEN MAYNE
2.0% RESIDENTS FIRST:STOP THE RATES RIP-OFF!
6.5% SHANAHAN CHAMBERLIN FOR MELBOURNE
0.5% COMMUNITY AND BUSINESS LEADERSHIP
0.5% COMMUNITY AND BUSINESS LEADERSHIP
2.0% FORWARD TOGETHER
17.0% THE GREENS
36.0% TEAM DOYLE
6.5% MORGAN ELLIOTT- PROSPERITY FOR LIVEABILITY
18.5% GARY SINGER - JOHN SO MELBOURNE LIVING
1.5% Ungrouped

Another C9 outcome: Greens fight it out with Mayne for a second candidate

In this percentage breakdown supplied by a ALP numbers guru. The results are more or less the same with Stephen Mayne losing out to the Greens Rohan Leppert.  This is a common outcome and much depends on the magnitude of the Singer John So Ticket


Elected Candidate Group
1  LOUEY, Kevin TEAM DOYLE
2  OKE, Cathy THE GREENS
3  WOOD, Arron TEAM DOYLE
4  PINDER-MORTIMER, Beverley TEAM DOYLE
5  ONG, Ken MELBOURNE LIVING
6  CHAMBERLIN, Kevin SHANAHAN CHAMBERLIN FOR MELBOURNE
7  WATTS, Jackie MORGAN ELLIOTT- PROSPERITY FOR LIVEABILITY
8  FOSTER, Richard OUR MELBOURNE
9  LEPPERT, Rohan THE GREENS

 
Percentage Group Name
5.5% OUR MELBOURNE
4.5% STEPHEN MAYNE
1.5% RESIDENTS FIRST:STOP THE RATES RIP-OFF!
7.0% SHANAHAN CHAMBERLIN FOR MELBOURNE
0.8% COMMUNITY AND BUSINESS LEADERSHIP
0.8% COMMUNITY AND BUSINESS LEADERSHIP
5.5% FORWARD TOGETHER
16.0% THE GREENS
38.7% TEAM DOYLE
9.0% MORGAN ELLIOTT- PROSPERITY FOR LIVEABILITY
9.5% GARY SINGER - JOHN SO MELBOURNE LIVING
1.3% Ungrouped

More C9 Analysis: Melbourne City Council 2012

A more realistic analysis of the outcome of the Melbourne City Council Election 

Shows Team Doyle dropping in primary vote with Gary Singer's Melbourne Living picking up a larger share of percentages on the back of John So's (Sr) name.


Elected Candidate Group
1  LOUEY, Kevin Team Doyle
2  OKE, Cathy The Greens
3  ONG, Ken Melbourne Living
4  WOOD, Arron Team Doyle
5  PINDER-MORTIMER, Beverley Team Doyle
6  CHAMBERLIN, Kevin SHANAHAN CHAMBERLIN FOR MELBOURNE
7  FOSTER, Richard OUR MELBOURNE
8  WATTS, Jackie MORGAN ELLIOTT- PROSPERITY FOR LIVEABILITY
9  LEPPERT, Rohan The Greens

Analysis based on percentage allocation supplied by B*
 

Percentage Group Name
7.0% OUR MELBOURNE
3.0% STEPHEN MAYNE
2.0% RESIDENTS FIRST:STOP THE RATES RIP-OFF!
9.5% SHANAHAN CHAMBERLIN FOR MELBOURNE
0.5% COMMUNITY AND BUSINESS LEADERSHIP
0.5% COMMUNITY AND BUSINESS LEADERSHIP
1.5% FORWARD TOGETHER
18.0% THE GREENS
33.0% TEAM DOYLE
6.0% MORGAN ELLIOTT- PROSPERITY FOR LIVEABILITY
16.0% GARY SINGER - JOHN SO MELBOURNE LIVING
3.0% Ungrouped