Tuesday, February 05, 2013

City Smokers sigh a sign of relief

Melbourne's Smokers cam rest assured that the City will not impose a blanket outside ban on smoking.  Cr Richard Foster's propsed smoking ban had no support and the issue was not included for discussion on tonight's Council agenda.

Discussion with various Councillors it was made clear that Foster did not have any support. The Council would not be imposing a local law that they can not police or implement.  Instead of the big bother heavy handed approach Council would embark on a more passive educational exercise to try and discourage smokers from lighting up. The Council may extend non-smoking areas to Council managed property, kindergartens, playgounds and the like but smoekers will not be targeted in a blanket city ban.

Richard Foster who is a member of the ALP was not endorsed by the Party and the proposed citywide smoking ban is not ALP policy. Foster has no mandate for his proposal. A proposal, if implemented, that  could cost the ALP two inner city Federal seats at the next Federal election. (Melbourne and Port Melbourne)

So outraged at the push and shove approach of the  City Council there were plans to mobilize city smokers in what would have been a firestorm of protest.  A campaign that would have called on the State Government to remove or subject to legislative oversight the establishment of local laws with the State Government and Governor in Council having the final say and right of veto of any proposed local law that is enacted that compromised state interests  Calls for tighter limitations on Council's right to impose restrictive laws in isolation or with-out a referedum. A proposal that, if adopted, would hamstring all municipalities in passing local laws.

The Foster Smoking ban would have had a negative impact on public health campaigns and made their job that much harder.

Richard Foster having had his citywide ban extinguished is now expected to change tact in order to save face. He will seek to have selective bans imposed instead, but never the less his grandstanding proposal will leave a stain on his reputation.


Anonymous said...

We need to at least ban smoking in Alfresco dining areas as a start. I can get away from people smoking in the street. But I will not only eat indoors while smokers enjoy the lovely outdoor dining Melbourne has to offer.

Come on Melbourne. Smoking is bad for you and others. QUIT!

MelbCity said...

Targeted selective smoking bans Yes. Could be a condition of Street trading permit otherwise should be left to the proprietor/business owner

BUT a blanket ban, as proposed by Richard Foster. is counter productive and unworkable. Grandstanding at its worst.

I hate smoking too.. But I think the Foster "Nanny state" proposal is wrong, ill considered. It is not ALP policy. Plays into the hands of the Greens control freaks providing the LNP with a free kick

Post a Comment